Monday, 21 December 2009

Portsmouth was the lowest of the low for Liverpool FC




NEVER mind how many days left until Christmas, how many days left until the football season is over?

It's 139 by my calculations and if Saturday against Portsmouth was a barometer of how the rest of the season will go, May 9th can't come soon enough.

The 2-0 defeat at Fratton Park was the worst of the lot this season. And there's been a lot. Seven now in the league, a situation that has left the Reds eight points from the coveted fourth spot and the invitation to continue to dine at Europe's top table that comes with it.

With trips to Villa Park, Old Trafford, The Emirates and Eastlands still to come, plus home games with Spurs and Chelsea, further defeats in the league must be considered likely on current form.

Whatever way you look at it, no matter what mitigating circumstances are presented, it's a grim time to be a Liverpool fan.

No back-to-back wins since September and just four wins in 17 would ring alarm bells at any football club.

Most fans seem desperate to lay the blame at someone's door - be it Rafa Benitez, Tom Hicks and George Gillett, or the players.

The truth is, everyone has played a part.

Fans that fell from the optimistic tree continued to dig for reasons for the defeat to bottom of the league Pompey.

From the harsh sending off of Javier Mascherano to the fitness and form of players, exceptional finishing by Portsmouth and even the pitch.

Calling it as I saw it, it was down to predictable play and fragile confidence.

Even with 11 men on the pitch, Liverpool barely made a chance worthy of the name. Daniel Agger headed over when he should of scored, Dirk Kuyt swung at the air when well placed in the box and Fernando Torres had a speculative shot from outside the area.

And that was about that.

Once Mascherano was given his marching orders out came the white flag, in went the towel and it never looked like anything else but a home win.

And that was what really grated. Did every player bust a gut to try and get something from the game? Did they squeeze out every last bead of sweat in an effort to salvage a point for the club that pays their hefty wages? Did they take some responsibility, grab the game by the scruff of the neck, go for broke? No, no, no.

But it can be done. And it can be done by a Liverpool team managed by Benitez.

Rewind to March 2006, an Anfield derby. Steven Gerrard is sent for an early bath after just 18 minutes. Rabid Evertonians celebrate in the Anfield Road end like they've just won the FA Cup. With not even a quarter of the game on the clock, and the score at 0-0, they sense victory.

Cue team spirit, hard work and passion. Liverpool steamroller the Blues with a high-tempo approach that the Toffees can't cope with and win the game 3-1.

That performance compared to the one on Saturday is like comparing Pele to Phil Neville. 

Next question - why?

 It was a strong enough line up on Saturday, and clearly one that Benitez felt could win the game, so why a performance so meek? It came on the back of a win over Wigan - didn't that lift confidence?

Clearly not. What's worrying for me is the play has been pedestrian for some time, even in victories, and teams seem to be getting the measure of Liverpool.

Portsmouth followed Fulham in allowing the Reds possession and sitting deep but while they saw a lot more of the ball Liverpool did little with it in the final third.

Benitez's insistence on sticking with out of form players is not helping matters. I'm a big fan of the Spaniard, he's brought the club forward in his time in charge and provided some truly memorable moments but that does not mean he is absolved of blame for the current crisis.

Kuyt is crying out for a rest, he's clearly far from his best, as is Emiliano Insua. Yet still they start matches. The Dutchman's touch and decision making has deserted him while the young Argentinean, still a great prospect, needs a spell out of the firing line as he is regularly being exposed and found out of position.

Stubborness is the chink in Benitez's armour. And the longer he persists with the policy of trying to play certain players into form, that chink will get bigger.

Petulant behaviour to the media doesn't help either, the 'perfect' diatribe may have been born of frustration but it just gave Liverpool's many knockers another stick to bash the club, and Benitez, with - an invitation they duly accepted with relish.

Just as Rafa is not immune to criticism, neither is Gerrard. He is a shadow of his former self. Still injured, not fit, struggling for form or fed up? We can only speculate from the outside looking in. But the skipper hasn't hit a ball in anger that I can recall since returning to the side. He looks off the pace and his body language, while never great, is even worse than usual.

Other players are going backwards. Glen Johnson looked a world beater a few weeks ago. But his confidence must be flimsier than Fabio Aurelio's limbs, because one own goal later he looks a bag of nerves.

So what now, what's the answer?

Well the club acting like a club would be a start. The players, the manager and the owners need to collectively pull their fingers out and start working for the common cause.

The owners need to stop behaving like the landlords of a dodgy student house. It's all well and good paying a two-bit decorator to paint the walls but if you don't pay the big bucks to tackle the dry rot, it'll come back to bite you on the arse.

I'd like to see them take their rigid business plan and throw it in the Mersey. Instead, recognise the problems on the playing side and stump up some cash for a bit of January window shopping. And  preferably in Harrods rather than the dump bin at Netto.

On the playing side, every player needs to look in the mirror and say am I trying my hardest? Am I being professional? Quite a few players need to ditch the petulance and play like they mean it.

For Rafa, I'd like to see him throw off the shackles. The Pompey line up was cautious and caution sends out the wrong message, certainly to fans and maybe to players, too.

Danny Pacheco showed enough against Fiorentina to suggest he would not be out of his depth, so play him. Bring him on, let him do his stuff. It would send out better vibes than Jay Spearing coming on for Lucas in the 88th minute...

The fear of the unknown could at the very least unnerve some opposition defenders.

My worry is that if things don't change quickly, the Americans' fingers will pull the trigger.

If Hicks and Gillett read it that Rafa is not the right man to protect their 'asset' I have no doubt they will fire him. Non-football men with power in football is a dangerous thing. Ask Mark Hughes.

If that happens then where will Liverpool be? My guess is up shit creek..without a paddle.

Because make no mistake, if Liverpool are looking for a new manager in the next few months there's a very real chance it won't be at the top end of the market.

Endless internet forum posts talk about Jose Mourinho and Guus Hiddink but let's be serious here. Neither will struggle for job offers, so why choose to voluntarily join the dysfunctional family that is Liverpool FC?

Warring owners, bickering fans, huge debt, no money to spend and a proviso that you must sell to buy. Hiddink? Mourinho? Don't make me laugh. More likely a 'second tier' manager keen to prove themselves or an ex-player with an emotional tie to the club. Either option is a step down from Benitez.

And mediocre managers spells mediocre players, then the downward spiral really will start.

Portsmouth was the lowest of the low for Liverpool this season. Let's hope now the only way is up from here on in.

Comments (13)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Confidence comes from the backline. Lack of confidence at the back four seems to be causing us to be ultra cautious when going forward. The backpass to Reina from inside the opponents half has been more frequently used than any other time recently. Just look at how teams have looked more confident in playing United recently.
It is getting increasingly hard to not loose faith and I understand the fans frustrations with Rafa because of his stubborness and predicatability. You know that he will always play Kuyt and that he will never sub him off; you know that he will rarely sub anyone under 60 minutes. You can also predicate how the team will line up regardless of who is playing and he will insist on two holding mid fielders.
I don't want to see him go because you can bet London to a brick we will end up with someone from fourth division or whatever. But I do wish he would stop being so stubborn; otherwise the Yanks will get rid of him and they have no idea what this great club is about
It wasnt just the defeat, as you say robbo, it was the manner of the defeat that was so worrying. Torres spent most of the game sulking because he was getting no protection from the ref, nor was he getting any protection from his players and his captain. Gerrard should have been speaking to the referee when Masch got sent off, instead he allowed the Portsmouth players to get him sent off by their reaction. The referee was a disgrace anyway, offering us little or no protection from the constant kicks and nibbles from Portsmouth players but then we didnt help ourselves either. I have never been more angry nor frustrated than I was on Saturday but this wont get any better. We have Wolves on Boxing Day and then Villa away, I can only see us losing one of them.
les munson's avatar

les munson · 795 weeks ago

a very good article written by yourself and very true the only thing i will add is although i am a great supporter of rafa are the players?
they go onto the pich looking so disinterested it makes me wonder whats going on, when do you see rafa console any of his players or show them any feeling ,the answer is hardly ever.
rafa is the best manager we could possibly have but i do feel he needs to show his players that he does care about them and then hopefully they will respond and go out there to do the job they get payed for and that is to play football the way we all know they are capable of
"Warring owners, bickering fans, huge debt, no money to spend and a proviso that you must sell to buy. Hiddink? Mourinho? Don't make me laugh. More likely a 'second tier' manager keen to prove themselves or an ex-player with an emotional tie to the club. Either option is a step down from Benitez.

And mediocre managers spells mediocre players, then the downward spiral really will start."

Benitez was mediocre when he was at Valencia and after he won a title there - a world class club like us made him even bigger at Anfield. Benitez is washed up and has no more capacity to take us further than where we are now. Those options you mentioned are more realistic than another 4 years or so of Benitez at Anfield - and you know it. A step-down is probably what we need. No point looking up to a manager with high expectations but no results. I'd rather watch a 2nd tier or ex-player manager be given the chance, improve the squad and not waste opportunities that should have been taken long, long time before. We need new blood and new perspectives, not the same old bullshit tactics. Mediocre managers in the league have brought in, and done more with mediocre players than Rafa has with his professionals. If not we wouldn't be this shite this season.
1 reply · active 794 weeks ago
Something about your post told me that you arrived here with an agenda...oh, that's it, your name!
Robbo, what's going on? I keep commenting on your blog, instead of you on mine and again, I find myself nodding my head and agreeing with you! That's twice in a row, nearly a run!

Excellent post mate, well balanced and lets hope that things pick up soon!

Did you catch my post yesterday and if so do you agree that a shake up is needed?
First of all. Rafa started 1 keeper + 4 defender + 2 defensive midfielders + 1 defender on the left + kuyt on the right. Against a team in the bottom of the league! It's so cautios I almost cried when I heard the line-up. I really think that it's unbalanced team. Many hard workers but not enough creativity to create something. Relying solely on Gerrard and Torres axe simply is not good enough, especially when one of them is struggling to get in form.

Second. Rafa choose Kuyt week in week out. I think it's on the expense of other players, mainly Bennayoun. Yossi is more effective when he was on the right side (look at wigan's game and compare it to arsenal when he's not effective on the left) and it's really disheartening when he get dropped whilst Kuyt will be playing no matter what.

Third. Why choose Insua in the first place? Why not Aurelio in the first place?

Fourth. Using 2 defensive midfielder (lucas and mascherano) doesn't make our defending better if we keep on loosing possesion. In the second half of arsenal's game, everytime Lucas or Mascherano pick the ball from the center back, both denilson and fabregas pressed them, Lucas then passed sideways or back to Carra/Agger and then boom, the hoofing begin (as if we had the players who can win header). That's what happen this season, when our opponent play a high tempo game and pressed our midfield. And now compare it to Wigan's game when Gerrard was playing as CM and distribute the ball (albeit not in his standard). We played Carra as a right back that game, but our defending is good because we distributed the ball well. And guess what? Lucas came, we play 2 DM, and boom, we conceded. It's not that I blame Lucas, but using 2 DM without one who had the ability to distribute the ball is weakening.

Fifth. Blaming Agger for missing the header is a poor example. The truth is we didn't create enough chances. Bar the deflected one, we didn't even make a single shot on target. Against effing Portsmouth!

Rafa always have a choice. He could put Gerrard back in the midfield and then bought another striker or a 'diego'. He could put Gerrard back in the midfield while waiting for Aquilani. He could play Yossi instead of Kuyt. He could abandon 4-2-3-1 when it's clearly not as effective when we had alonso. The list go on..

For me Rafa is great manager, and I have faith he will turn it around. But he really need to be responsible for his choices this season. And I refused to think that questioning some of his choises made me any less of a supporter.

PS: The players also need to share the responsibility. What a gutless performances. I wish rafa made all the players watch the replay video and made them donate their paycheck this week to HJC.
1 reply · active 794 weeks ago
Agree with some of your points, although I don' t see what is wrong with saying Agger should have scored the header! A professional footballer should be able to get a header on target from six yards surely? I'm sure if you asked him he'd say the same!
Oh my, I posted on the wrong site :( I read 2 blogs at the same time and write 2 comment on notepad, one for you and for the other. Please, please, delete the comment if it's not appropriate.

*feels really embarrassed*
i think Rafa has got it wrong most games this season and due to his nature i dont think thinkgs will change. at least come end of season he will be out of a job because the 4th spot is a long way away
After staying up to 4am in the morning to watch this game, all I can express is my disapointment at the lack of any cohesion but more importantly the lack of flair. As others have said this was a cautious team. We needed to take a leaf out of Portsmouth book as they played as if their life depended on it, while we did not show the same committment. On paper we should have won easily. So whats the problem

No 1) The other clubs know how Rafa plays and have countered this so Rafa needs to change the way he plays which will mean players being dropped and new players in the squad being given a chance. He needs to be more flexible in his management style. It seems ever since his famous rant, the club has slowly gone backwards.

No2) Watching the team play and taking account some of the rumours, it appears Anfield is not a happy place. Everyone knows a happy workplace is very important to a successful operation.

I suggest that unless things improve, Rafa's days are limited and we need to do something now or we will finish in the bottom half of the league, 3 wins in 15 games just is not good enough
Jamie Ward's avatar

Jamie Ward · 794 weeks ago

That was a very well written article Robbo, most impressed - Jamie Ward

Post a new comment

Comments by